Tomorrow's Teaching and Learning
The posting below takes a new look at student journal keeping and what it takes to make them effective. It is by James Rhem, executive editor of the National Teaching and Learning Forum [http://www.ntlf.com]. This posting is #47 in a series of selected excerpts from the NT&LF newsletter reproduced here as part of our "Shared Mission Partnership." NT&LF has a wealth of information on all aspects of teaching and learning. If you are not already a subscriber, you can check it out at [http://www.ntlf.com/] The on-line edition of the Forum--like the printed version - offers subscribers insight from colleagues eager to share new ways of helping students reach the highest levels of learning. December, Vol. 19, No. 1, 2009. Copyright © 2009 James Rhem & Associates, LLC. © Copyright 1996-2009. Published by James Rhem & Associates, Inc. All rights reserved worldwide. Reprinted with permission.
UP NEXT: Explaining the Reasons for Criticisms of Students' Academic Performance
Tomorrow's Teaching and Learning
---------------------------------- 1,641 words ---------------------------------
Until I sat in on a conference session last year led by Dannelle Stevens and Joanne Cooper, I'd had very little respect for or interest in journaling. I'd published pieces on it, of course. It was one of the new things being used in teaching and naturally deserved attention in the Forum, but as a fellow who'd never been able to keep a diary and one who could not conceive of how students could be asked to share their most honest thoughts and feelings and then be graded on them, the whole business seemed bogus to me. Moreover, all the experiences of journaling I'd heard of from students went something like this: They'd be given a sheaf of articles to read and write journal entries on. These would be due at a certain date and inevitably students waited until that date, read the articles hastily, and wrote their one-page reflections just in time for the deadline. To me, it all sounded like busy work with a trendy new name-"journaling."
Indeed, Stevens doesn't think much of that sort of journaling. "I think where profs go wrong is when they tell students to do a reading and then go home and reflect on it.
Uh uh . . . Students put it off, they resent it, and you don't get what you want from them. They aren't really reflective. It's just more busy work that the teacher requires."
The Book on Journals
But where Stevens and I found agreement on what journaling often is and shouldn't be, she and Joanne Cooper, coauthors of Journal Keeping: How to Use Reflective Writing for Learning, Teaching, Professional Insight, and Positive Change (Stylus 2009) have a deep understanding of the good that can come from journaling.
Part of their understanding comes from seeing how and why many faculty go wrong in their efforts to use journals. "Faculty are coming from a place where they want to get students actively engaged," says Stevens, "and they think this is a way to do it. But the only way journaling works is to have a variety of activities, and to begin to get students accustomed to the idea that they will be surprised by their writing, and that they can and will find some interesting stuff to work with from that."
Rich Surprises in Writing
Surprises? Yes, surprises. While Stevens has her students interact with their journals in a wide and creative variety of ways, the thinking lying behind the whole endeavor owes much to Peter Elbow's influential work on the process of writing in such books as Writing without Teachers. "Writing is thinking," says Stevens. "That's what I tell my students. They think it's what's done after they think."
Happily for me, Elbow's books began to come out just when I needed them; indeed, without the inspiration I drew from them, I wonder if I ever would have finished my dissertation. So, when Stevens cites Elbow, she's immediately put a lot of points on the board toward persuading me that journaling can work, because, through Elbow, I see how. Stevens and Cooper embrace Elbow's technique of "freewriting" fully. Of freewriting, Elbow writes:
"Not a perfect stream of consciousness.
It is private writing and may or may not
be lucid and organized. Anything goes.
Freewriting is writing without pauses.
"It invites surprise. Students often
discover things they didn't know they
thought or felt. The deepest insights often
come after ten or fifteen minutes when
writers initially feel they have run out of
things to say. Writers should generate a
lot of ideas to allow them to keep only the
best ones for the finished draft."
Echoing Elbow, Stevens adds, "If you don't get a surprise in your writing you wouldn't keep writing. You have to put aside your belief that nothing will come of this [freewriting]."
And so Stevens convinces students that letting go, forgetting punctuation and grammar and just keeping the pen, pencil, or keyboard moving for a period of time will bring something worthwhile to the surface. "In journals they are the source of the text. They express who they are in that journaling activity. They develop their own voice; they affirm their own voice." And so in journaling, students- writers-become confronted with an objective trace of their own thoughts and feelings, something to interact with, to build on, something
that will not only help them write their final papers, but help make those papers better products of their learning.
Owning Your Learning
Stevens first had students keep journals in a course in action research she was teaching at Portland State. "The students weren't owning their projects," she says. "This was sort of a pedantic activity for them: They'd read the research, and they thought 'Okay, I just go through these steps: I read the literature, I form a problem, and then I do my method.' They were not invested at all, really. They were just following directions." That wasn't good enough: "I know that when students are invested in what they're doing they learn more," Stevens says, and so she imposed the journals as a way to provoke investment.
Personally, Stevens prefers a handwritten journal. She carries hers everywhere. The inside cover of Journal Keeping reproduces a page from her journal showing the elaborate system of categorization and filing she has worked out for her own journal. She doesn't require anything like that for her students. "I suggest they use it in their life-take it to meetings, make notes on reading, etc. I require them to use it in class," she says.
How She Does It
That in-class use may include keeping lecture notes in the journal, but the required use usually works something like this: First, Stevens asks students to take out their journals and write in them for five or ten minutes. She doesn't tell them what to write about, just to write. Later on in class, she'll say: "Okay, now I want you to think of some project or problem or concern that you are interested in and then do a focused freewrite on it." This is something related to their research project.
"The first activity warms them up so that the second is better. That's my typical procedure-a freewrite to get the dust off the road, make them more present in the class, then a focused freewrite."
Reflection tends to move students' cognitive development upwards in the well-known Bloom Taxonomy of cognition, but it can advance them in affective development as well, Stevens maintains. "Those higher Bloom levels are important to me-analysis and synthesis-but also creativity," she says. "A journal is a safer place to explore creatively. If we want students to engage and be motivated, compare ideas, and so on, they become more active learners when they have to write about it in a journal and interact with the subject creatively." To encourage creative interaction, Stevens may suggest students write a dialogue in their journal between an imagined figure and an ideal interlocutor, or some other fancy freeing writing.
Arrrrrggh . . . Grading
Of course anything a teacher assigns must be met with some level of feedback to be meaningful to students. Some faculty grade journals according to rubrics they share with students. Stevens doesn't grade them, but she does respond to them, or rather to meta-reflections on them. "I don't want to slog through all that stuff; I want them to slog through it at the end of the term," says Stevens. "I have them go back and read their journal and select two entries to photocopy for me and then type a one-page reflection on why each was an important entry for them. Sometimes they put lecture notes in there and they may say, that was so good the way you talked about paradigms, or whatever. I have a rubric for assessing those meta-reflections. And it asks how much they refer to the text itself-quotes from their own journal related to course content or something learned in the course, asks whether the reflection touches on whether the journaling has extended to their personal or professional lives (how useful), and so on. I also look for whether they've been critical of their own work, and whether they see their own growth.
"Scoring the meta-reflection is hard, I admit."
The amount of extra work faculty take on when they do journaling right results in such notable gains in the quality of students' learning, says Stevens, that she's always found it worthwhile.
Some students meet required journaling with the same resistance I'd long felt to it. How does Stevens persuade them? To some extent, she doesn't. "I tell them it's not a choice," she says. "But they get persuaded when they find themselves surprised by what they've written." In addition, students become persuaded by the way Stevens models the activity. "I write along with them," she says. When she calls for a freewrite, she does a freewrite at the same time. When she calls for a focused freewrite, she writes too. "Students like models," she says. "They respond well to examples of what others have done." In that same vein, she often combines the journaling activity with another effective pedagogy. She'll invite students to share what they've written with a fellow student before the class as a whole takes up the topic. Indeed, she may suggest that students may want to find a "journal buddy" with whom they share their writing regularly through the semester. Those who do, usually find the experience a rich and deepening one.
Of journaling overall Steven's says, "It affects the level of engagement if you do it right-and there are a lot of people who do it wrong- if it is integrated with your course and students have a variety of ways to use the journal it makes a big difference in their learning."
Curriculum & Instruction - Education
Portland State University
PO Box 751
Portland, OR 97207
Telephone: (503) 725-4679